How to choose
Rules or AI. Rules do exactly what you say and nothing else; AI handles files whose names say nothing, like scan0001.pdf. Lisorto does both: built-in rules first, AI for the rest, and your own rules on top.
Where your files are read. A file organizer reads invoices, contracts, and scans. Check whether that happens on your Mac or on someone’s server, and whether you can turn the cloud off.
Seeing moves first. The first run moves hundreds of files. An app that shows the whole plan and undoes it in one click makes that first run safe.
Finding files afterwards. Sorting helps, but most of the time you are looking for one file. Search inside files, scans included, is what makes a tidy folder useful.